Quality seals and certificates

In order to make the right choices from the wide ran­ge of pro­ducts offe­red by various manu­fac­tu­rers and brands when shop­ping for food, many con­su­mers use seals and cer­ti­fi­ca­tes as a gui­de. The­se were ori­gi­nal­ly crea­ted to asso­cia­te pro­ducts with cer­tain cha­rac­te­ris­tics and to pro­vi­de con­su­mers with a basis for making decisi­ons. The seals of appro­val can be clas­si­fied accord­ing to envi­ron­men­tal or social aspects as well as accord­ing to the pro­duct groups to which they refer.

In Ger­ma­ny the­re are now over 1000 dif­fe­rent qua­li­ty seals, marks of ori­gin and sym­bols. Accord­in­gly, food pack­a­ging is cor­re­spon­din­gly color­ful. Only very few of the seals are based on legal foun­da­ti­ons. A lar­ge num­ber of the sym­bols are pri­va­te labels or pri­va­te test marks. For the con­su­mer, this seal and cer­ti­fi­ca­ti­on land­s­cape is pri­ma­ri­ly con­fu­sing. Many labels and their lack of trans­pa­ren­cy make it dif­fi­cult to choo­se sui­ta­ble foods and iden­ti­fy their ori­gin based on one’s own values.

With regard to aquacul­tu­re, the­re is also a gre­at need for infor­ma­ti­on, as various recent stu­dies have shown, inclu­ding the stu­dy of the BÖLN (Bun­des­pro­gramm Öko­lo­gi­scher Land­bau und ande­re For­men nach­hal­ti­ger Land­wirt­schaft) „Kreis­lauf­an­la­gen – Posi­tio­nen des Öko­sek­tors” (Recir­cu­la­ti­on sys­tems – Posi­ti­ons of the eco-sec­tor). Alt­hough fish far­ming has been inte­gra­ted into the EU orga­nic regu­la­ti­on sin­ce 2009, modern recir­cu­la­ti­on sys­tems are cur­r­ent­ly exclu­ded from the regu­la­ti­on. The „near-natu­ral“ far­ming methods men­tio­ned abo­ve are not com­pa­ti­ble with recir­cu­la­ti­on sys­tems that place the fish in plastic tanks.

“(11) Recent tech­ni­cal deve­lo­p­ment has led to incre­a­sing use of clo­sed recir­cu­la­ti­on sys­tems for aquacul­tu­re pro­duc­tion, such sys­tems depend on exter­nal input and high ener­gy but per­mit reduc­tion of was­te dischar­ges and pre­ven­ti­on of escapes. Due to the princip­le that orga­nic pro­duc­tion should be as clo­se as pos­si­ble to natu­re the use of such sys­tems should not be allo­wed for orga­nic pro­duc­tion until fur­ther know­ledge is avail­ab­le. Excep­tio­nal use should be pos­si­ble only for the spe­ci­fic pro­duc­tion situa­ti­on of hat­che­ries and nur­se­ries.”
(Com­mis­si­on Regu­la­ti­on (EC) No 710/2009 of 5 August 2009)

The con­cept of being clo­se to natu­re and the ques­ti­on of which new rese­ar­ches are necessa­ry were taken up and con­tro­ver­si­al­ly dis­cus­sed in Naturland’s sta­ke­hol­der stu­dy. It can be said that every aquacul­tu­re is arti­fi­cial in its­elf, but the recir­cu­la­ti­on sys­tem makes it „far from natu­re“, espe­cial­ly sta­ted by the con­su­mer. This con­su­mer often trans­fers his know­ledge and per­cep­ti­ons of live­stock and poul­try far­ming (fac­to­ry far­ming) to fish far­ming and thus jud­ges it main­ly emo­tio­nal­ly and unob­jec­tively. Com­pa­red to other fish far­ming prac­ti­ces, howe­ver, clo­sed recir­cu­la­ti­on sys­tems have nume­rous advan­ta­ges in terms of the environment:

  • con­ser­va­ti­on of stocks in natu­ral waters
  • no dischar­ge of excre­ments and resi­du­es into natu­ral waters
  • reduc­tion of water consumption
  • reduc­tion of trans­port distances
  • con­trol of the fish stock, no escape to sur­roun­ding ecosystems
  • food safe­ty

In order to gua­ran­tee a qua­li­ta­ti­ve cha­rac­te­riz­a­ti­on of fish farms in the future and to legi­ti­mi­ze the eco-cer­ti­fi­ca­ti­on pro­ce­du­res for recir­cu­la­ti­on sys­tems, the defi­ni­ti­on of the EC Eco Regu­la­ti­on must be divi­ded into con­cre­te eva­lua­ti­on points. Cri­te­ria such as „clo­se to natu­re“ and „ani­mal-friend­ly live­stock far­ming“ must be spe­ci­fied in their requi­re­ments so that each plant can be eva­lua­ted individually.

Even though the­re is cur­r­ent­ly no cer­ti­fi­ca­ti­on pos­si­bi­li­ty for clo­sed recir­cu­la­ting aquacul­tu­re, the fol­lowing is a brief intro­duc­tion to the most important labels:

EU Bio-Label
This label can be found on pro­ducts in which at least 95% of the ingre­dients come from orga­nic far­ming and which con­tain a maxi­mum of 0.9% gene­ti­cal­ly modi­fied mate­ri­als. Sin­ce 2010, the­re is an indi­vi­du­al sec­tion of orga­nic aquacul­tu­re, in which it is regu­la­ted that the sto­cking den­si­ty may not exceed 25 kg per m3 (varies accord­ing to spe­ci­es). In clo­sed recir­cu­la­ti­on sys­tems only brood and young ani­mals may be kept. Only orga­ni­cal­ly pro­du­ced feed is allo­wed as feed and for car­ni­vo­r­ous fish cer­tain vege­ta­ble ingre­dients are only restric­ted­ly approved.

Sin­ce the mid-1990s, the Natur­land Asso­cia­ti­on for Orga­nic Far­ming, foun­ded in 1982, has also had gui­de­li­nes for aquacul­tu­re. Only feed­s­tuffs that meet the­se stan­dards may be used. In addi­ti­on, the sto­cking den­si­ty must not exceed 10 kg per m3 (varies accord­ing to the spe­ci­es of fish). Fur­ther­mo­re, no che­mi­cals may be used, and the ani­mals may not be rea­red in arti­fi­cial con­tai­ners. The­re­fo­re, this label cate­go­ri­cal­ly exclu­des the far­ming in clo­sed recir­cu­la­ti­on systems.

Ger­man Bio-Label
The Ger­man equi­va­lent of the EU eco-label is also based on EU legis­la­ti­on and is the­re­fo­re usual­ly found bes­i­de the EU label on the pro­duct pack­a­ging. It is aimed ther­eby like­wi­se at a „kind-fair ani­mal hus­bandry“ and a care­ful, las­ting and thus eco­lo­gi­cal production.

Fol­lowing on from the MSC label for wild caught fish pro­ducts, the ASC seal for respon­si­ble aquacul­tu­re has been in exis­tence sin­ce 2009. The stan­dard cri­te­ria are the tracea­bi­li­ty of the ori­gin of the fish feed (not from over­fi­shed stocks, GMO decla­red), the ban on gene­ti­cal­ly modi­fied ani­mals, sui­ta­bi­li­ty of the loca­ti­on for the far­med fish, low mor­ta­li­ty rate during the bree­ding peri­od, gua­ran­tee of a good water qua­li­ty and medi­cal­ly moni­to­red use of anti­bio­tics exclu­si­ve­ly for the tre­at­ment of sick animals.

In the mean­ti­me, docu­men­ta­ti­ons of the acti­vi­ties and cer­ti­fi­ca­ti­on pro­ce­du­res of MSC and ASC are avail­ab­le. With regard to the­se reports the ques­ti­on ari­ses whe­ther the pro­ducts cer­ti­fied with the­se labels are actual­ly still pro­du­ced accord­ing to the spe­ci­fied cri­te­ria and whe­ther one should trust in the label.

Other seals are for examp­le tho­se of Trans­pa­rent Fishe­ries, bio­Fi­sh, Sus­tainab­le Aquacul­tu­re, Debio, GGN and Gää.

​In sum­ma­ry, it can be said that con­su­mers today not only blind­ly trust prin­ted labels but should also form their own impres­si­on of pro­ducts and their ori­gin – espe­cial­ly in the fresh food sec­tor. In the cour­se of an incre­a­singly regio­nal sup­ply the con­su­mer is enab­led to main­tain con­ta­ct with the pro­du­cer and to con­vin­ce hims­elf of the pro­duc­tion con­di­ti­ons of the food in per­so­nal talks at the mar­ket or at the producer’s pre­mi­ses. In this way, the con­su­mer knows what ends on his pla­te and the pro­du­cer ulti­mate­ly expe­ri­en­ces more under­stan­ding and grea­ter appre­cia­ti­on of his product.

With this in mind, we will be dis­pen­sing with labels for the fore­see­ab­le future and would pre­fer to encou­ra­ge con­su­mers to find out about the ori­gin of the fish of their choice and to sup­port tho­se sup­pliers who best meet their values of fresh­ness, sus­taina­bi­li­ty and quality.


Pic­tu­re Source: SEAWATER Cubes

Newsletter abonnieren

Du möchtest regelmäßige Updates zu SEAWATER Cubes erhalten? In unserem monatlichen Newsletter informieren wir zu aktuellen Themen und Entwicklungen rund um unser Unternehmen. Außerdem warten spannende Fachbeiträge zum Thema Aquakultur sowie exklusive Informationen zu Veranstaltungen auf Dich.

Vielen Dank! Du hast Dich erfolgreich für unseren Newsletter angemeldet.